The study examines architectural criticism as an intellectual and professional practice that emerged around the eighteenth century but developed more slowly than criticism in literature and the arts. Analyzing 122 scholarly sources published between 1965 and 2025 through MAXQDA and open, axial, and selective coding, it develops a typology of architectural criticism based on its theoretical and epistemological foundations. Architectural criticism is understood as discourse shaped by the interaction of the architectural work, architect, audience, critic, and context. The study identifies 13 theoretical schools, ranging from Romantic and phenomenological to Marxist, postcolonial, ecological, and quantitative/technical criticism, and six epistemological foundations, including anti-positivism, subjectivism, interpretivism/constructivism, postmodernism, emancipatory approaches, functionalism, and positivism/postpositivism. Overall, it argues that architectural criticism is not merely aesthetic judgment but a multilayered intellectual practice shaped by philosophical assumptions, theoretical positions, contextual interpretations, and evaluative criteria.
Moghaddam N, Rezvani A, Sarvari H. An Analytical Framework for the Typology of Theoretical Schools of Architectural Criticism Conceived as Discourse: From Subjectivist to Objectivist Paradigms. , کیمیای هنر. 2026; 15 (59) :65-101 URL: http://kimiahonar.ir/article-1-2518-en.html